Is It Cheaper to Haul It Yourself? Winnipeg Fall Cleanout Costs Compared

Fall is when Winnipeg garages, basements and sheds get cleared out before winter. Once the pile is sorted, there is one question left: do you load it up and haul it to the City yourself, or rent a bin?

We rent bins, so you might expect us to say a bin is always cheaper. It is not. Per tonne, hauling it yourself costs less. What you are really comparing is the price per tonne against your time, your vehicle and the number of trips. Here is the honest breakdown.

Homeowner unloading a utility trailer beside a comparison view of a red driveway bin.
Self-hauling trades a lower tipping fee for vehicle use, trips and unloading. Illustrative comparison.

Where Winnipeg Residents Can Take a Load

For a household cleanout, Winnipeg residents normally use the Brady 4R Winnipeg Depot rather than the commercial landfill. Check the City’s current access rules before loading your vehicle.

The City runs three 4R Winnipeg Depots, at Brady Road, Pacific Avenue and Panet Road. Two rules matter most for a cleanout:

  • Garbage only goes to Brady. The City currently lists $81 per tonne with a $25 minimum. Pacific and Panet accept recycling, not garbage.
  • Accepted reusable, recyclable and compostable items can be dropped off free at the 4R depots. Check accepted materials before travelling.

The depots primarily accept household materials from Winnipeg residents. The City also permits qualifying small commercial customers through an application process; unapproved commercial vehicles are not permitted.

What Self-Hauling Really Involves

The tipping fee is the easy part to compare. The rest is about logistics.

You unload by hand, including self-dumping trailers. Whatever you lift into your truck or trailer must be taken out again at the depot.

Your trailer has limits. Dual-axle trailers may use the depots. The City directs trailers with more than two axles to the main entrance at 1777 Brady Road and applies tipping fees to the entire load. Confirm access for your vehicle before travelling.

You need the vehicle. Self-haul only works if you own, borrow or rent a truck or trailer that can carry the load. If you are renting one, add that cost to your side of the comparison.

You make the trips. A full fall cleanout rarely fits in one load. Each trip means loading, driving, waiting, unloading and driving back. To compare volumes, our 8-yard bin holds roughly 3 pickup truck loads, the 12-yard about 5, and the 20-yard about 8.

You sort as you go. Because only Brady takes garbage while recyclables and compostables are free, sorting saves money. It also means keeping the piles separate in your vehicle.

Household cleanout items secured in the bed of a parked pickup truck.
A suitable vehicle and a safely secured load are part of the self-haul plan. Illustrative image.

What a Bin Costs

Ecobins & Cartage bin rental is priced by size, with the first 7 days included:

BinPrice (7 days included)Holds about
8-yard$2503 pickup loads
12-yard$2755 pickup loads
20-yard$3008 pickup loads

Tipping is billed separately at $99 per tonne, based on the actual weight of your load. Delivery and pickup are part of the rate. We drop the bin on your driveway, you fill it at your own pace, and we haul it away. No loading a truck, no trips, no unloading by hand.

See full sizes and details on our bin rental page.

Garage cleanout sorted into cardboard recycling, yard waste and household garbage.
Separate accepted recycling and yard waste before comparing disposal costs. Illustrative image.

A Side-by-Side Example

Say your cleanout produces 1.5 tonnes of garbage, after you have pulled out the recyclables and compostables.

Self-haul to the Brady 4R Depot: 1.5 tonnes × $81 = $121.50 in tipping fees Plus your vehicle, fuel, time, trips and unloading by hand.

8-yard Ecobins bin: $250 rental + (1.5 tonnes × $99) = $398.50 Delivery, pickup and the 7-day rental included.

The difference on paper is real. The question is what the gap buys you. If you already own a truck or trailer, have a free weekend and can lift everything twice, self-hauling is the cheaper choice and we would tell you so. If you would need to rent a vehicle, make several trips, or would rather not spend a Saturday at the depot, the bin starts to make sense. These are illustrative subtotals, not final quotes; confirm applicable taxes, load restrictions and any additional charges.

Illustration comparing several self-haul trips with delivery and collection of one red bin.
Compare the full job: several trips and unloading versus one bin filled on site. Illustration.

Which Option Fits Your Cleanout

Haul it yourself if:

  • You have a suitable vehicle or a trailer with two axles or fewer
  • The load is small enough for one or two trips
  • You have the time and can unload by hand
  • A lot of it is recyclable or compostable and can go to a depot for free

Rent a bin if:

  • The cleanout is large, or mixes renovation debris with household junk
  • You do not have a truck or trailer
  • You want to fill it over several days instead of one long haul
  • Heavy lifting twice is not realistic for you

Not sure which size you need? Our guide to choosing a bin size in Winnipeg walks through it. Clearing leaves and yard waste? See fall leaf and yard waste bin rental. Comparing quotes from different companies? Read our cheap bin rental guide. And if the bin has to go on the street instead of your driveway, check our guide to street bin permits in Winnipeg.

FAQ

Can Winnipeg residents use the Brady Road landfill?

Household customers are normally directed to the Brady 4R Winnipeg Depot. Special vehicle and approved commercial access rules differ, so check with the City for your load.

How much does it cost to dump garbage at the Brady 4R Depot?

The City lists $81 per tonne with a minimum charge of $25. Garbage is only accepted at the Brady depot.

Is anything free at the 4R depots?

Yes. Items that are recyclable, reusable or compostable can be dropped off for free at the 4R Winnipeg Depots.

Do I have to unload my own trailer at the depot?

Yes. Residents must unload by hand, including self-dumping trailers.

What does an Ecobins bin cost?

$250 for an 8-yard, $275 for a 12-yard and $300 for a 20-yard, each with 7 days included and delivery and pickup in the rate. Tipping is $99 per tonne by actual weight.

Is it cheaper to haul junk myself?

Per tonne, yes. A bin saves the vehicle, the trips and the lifting.

Get a Bin Price

If the bin makes more sense for your cleanout, Ecobins & Cartage delivers 8, 12 and 20-yard bins across Winnipeg. Price your bin or call (431) 317-8581.

Sources and current rates

Rates checked October 30, 2026. See the City of Winnipeg 4R depot rules and fees, Brady Road landfill access information and Ecobins bin rental rates. Check current fees and accepted materials before booking or travelling.

Eco Bins roll-off bin on a Winnipeg driveway

Got a project? Get a bin.

Pick your size online or call the yard. We’ll lock in a delivery date that works for your job.